“Art?” Edward Cooney Jr. bellowed, his magnificent barrel chest puffing up and shirt bursting at the seams, a button popping out in blind rage and traveling with the velocity of a spitball so several of the trembling students duck and cower in fear, “You call this flaccid end of a weeping cock ART?”
The object is in the middle of the University gallery space, a red metal folding chair with the words “DO NOT SIT” written on graph paper pinned to the back. “And who,” continued the great Edward Cooney Jr., in that voice that has been described as ‘a steam locomotive rumbling out of a tunnel at full tilt’, “And who, can I ask, is the maestro responsible for this pile of rotting horseradish?”
The two dozen dazed and cowed students tried to press themselves against the walls of the gallery, but as they were taken up mostly by a large three piece painting made with dried sea-weed and kelp, and a sculpture in the corner of a fat man’s body without a head or arms, they had to content themselves by crowding together and looking at the floor. Then a skinny young man in a fedora and a black suit stepped forward with a determined grimace and said, “Do you even understand it? It’s supposed to elicit response. You have to interact with it, you have to say, if I can’t sit on it, what can I do? It’s a folding chair, so if you fold it you have to let it fall to the ground or lean it against a wall. And then, why are you listening to what a piece of paper says anyway? It’s a postmodern subversion of authority and function.”
“A postmodern subversion of authority and function eh?” Edward Cooney Jr. drawled, “Let me tell you about authority and function. In my authority I refuse to even look at your postmodern shit-pellet, I refuse to interact, to sit or fold or kick it, I refuse even to acknowledge it exists. And my function? My function is to destroy.”
And with that the mighty critic two generations have hailed as “the sharpest observer of our age” steamed over to the lone chair, picked it up over his head and flung it at its author. The artist ducked just in time but the chair crashed into the sculpture of the headless and armless fat man which shattered in two at the crotch. There was a stampede towards the door. The artist screamed, “You’re just a critic! You don’t even produce anything, all you do is whine from an armchair at home!”
“By God am I critic!” Edward Cooney Jr. boomed, “And. I. Will. Criticize.” And with that he let a monstrous fist fly at the startled face of the man with the fedora. A photographer captured the moment just before the punch landed, and it was this picture that made the photographer famous. A decade later the University did a retrospective on the photographer’s works, and ‘The Punch’ as the photograph was known held the place of pride. The great critic had died a few years before of a brain tumor. It was said that he had suffered a series of debilitating strokes and eventually had a hemorrhage. The artist who had made the chair dropped out of his program and went to live on a native reserve for several years working with a development program. He took peyote and proclaimed to have seen a prophetic vision. He now makes large sculptures in the Nevada desert that people like to dance under once a year. When asked about his art he would say, “A long time ago, before I was enlightened, I was punched in the face for a piece that I didn’t even make. After that I realized that the only way to live was to keep making things that got you punched in the face.”
He lives close to the desert and has many protégés. Once in awhile one of us will punch him in the face. Then we all have a nice laugh about it. He is a good man and we love him very much.


